How Brands Co-Author Culture

It’s 8:47 on a Monday morning. Something blew up overnight, and three people on the brand team have already dropped it in the group chat with the same question: should we jump on this? By lunch there’s a post. By Thursday nobody remembers it, including the team that made it.

Now picture a different Monday. A LEGO fan checks how many people have backed the set she designed and submitted to LEGO Ideas. If it reaches 10,000 supporters, LEGO will consider putting it into production, and she’ll earn 1% of net sales if it does. Nobody at LEGO had to chase anything. The community walked in the door with the idea.

The first brand is reacting to culture. The second is co-authoring it.

At The Gathering in Banff, I had the chance to moderate a panel with leaders from Labatt, Google and PepsiCo Canada, brands that have found their way to that second Monday. The conversation stayed with me. Shirley Mukerjea, Chief Marketing Officer, PepsiCo Foods Canada shared how her team centered themselves in the snacking culture within the world of gaming, Andrew Oosterhuis, Vice President Marketing, Labatt highlighted how the brand listened to fans and let them drive the launch of their Busch Apple product in a lesser known area, and Chris Chan, Head of Consumer & Retail Marketing, Google Canada, discussed Google’s process of being a utility for creators to connect with their audiences authentically. The thing they all had in common was taking the time to listen to their consumer, understand their needs, and create from there – not hopping on something hot for the moment.

What co-authoring actually means

Co-authoring culture means a community writes the story with you, and you help them write the next chapter. You bring resources they don’t have. They bring credibility you can’t buy. Both names go on the work.

I think of it as the difference between a tourist and a town builder. A tourist shows up for the weekend, puts on the local jersey for a photo and is gone by Monday. A town builder buys a storefront on Main Street, hires locals, sponsors the hockey team and is still there ten years later. Both get noticed. Only one becomes part of the place.

Six steps to co-author culture

  1. Start where you already belong. Before you look for a new subculture to enter, look at where people already use your product without being asked. Read the reviews, the Reddit threads, the comments under your competitors’ posts. Labatt didn’t invent the demand for Bapple. Fans were already asking for it.
  2. Map who’s holding the pen. Every community has people who shape it: creators, organizers, shop owners, the person who runs the group chat. Name them. If you can’t list ten people who matter in the space, you aren’t ready to show up there.
  3. Listen for friction, then pick one problem. Spend real time in the space before you say anything. Social listening helps, see them in person if possible. What you’re looking for is friction: something that costs the community time, money or access. Then pick one.
  4. Bring what only you can bring. Match the friction to an asset you actually own. Doritos’ Key Codes worked because it turned a real gaming annoyance into a reward, using something PepsiCo already had. If your contribution could come from any brand, it isn’t yours.
  5. Hand over the pen. Give the community real authorship. That means credit, decision rights and money. LEGO pays its fan designers a royalty. If legal and brand review strip out every trace of the community’s voice, the work stops being co-authored.
  6. Fund it like infrastructure. Put it in the budget as a multi-year line, not a campaign flight. Google has backed creators on YouTube since 2007, paying creators, artists and media companies more than $100 billion from 2021 to 2024 alone. That’s how YouTube became the place where so much of today’s culture gets written.

Then measure what compounds, and set those measures before launch: community retention, sentiment over time, conversation you didn’t pay for and pricing power. And be ready to say no. Before you commit, ask whether you’re adding real value or borrowing a look, whether it will still matter in six months, and whether the community would want it with your logo removed. Most ideas should fail at least one of those.

Where good intentions fall apart

The breakdown usually happens inside the building, after the idea is approved. A community program gets planned like a campaign, with a launch, a wrap report and nothing after, and leaving can do more damage than never showing up. Approvals wear it down until, by the fourth round of review, whatever made it feel real is gone. Agree early on what the community controls and what the brand controls. And if co-authoring lives in a side project with no budget owner, it won’t survive the next planning cycle. Someone senior has to own the relationship for years.

How Citizen helps brands co-author culture

We start with listening. We’ve built most of our intelligence technology ourselves, designed around how culture actually moves, and it’s run by a team that knows how to read what it finds, so you know who’s holding the pen before you pick one up.

From there, we build ideas the community helps write, and we take them wherever that community already lives. That might be the newsroom, a creator’s channel, a local event or a group chat. And we help clients plan for years, with measures that show whether the community is getting stronger.

If you were in the room in Banff, thank you for a great conversation. Whether you were there or not, reach out. We’d love to talk about what your brand could build, and who you could build it with.

Marketing to Gen Z Offline Starts With Friction

If you were born before 1997, you remember a portion of life lived completely offline: having to write down and keep track of phone numbers, tacking photographs to the fridge, making face-to-face contact for every transaction essential to life. 

For Gen Z, those memories form a shrinking minority of life. Education, socializing, romance, and every kind of transaction got increasingly convenient as worlds got smaller. 

Gen Z’s tastes are starting to shift. Life became too sterile, too simplified, too online, and too convenient. Now they want friction. 

We ran a survey of 5,604 consumers in the US and Canada and found that Gen Z (18-29) isn’t anti-social, but they suffer from micro-social friction. Our research found that over 70% of Gen Z want more opportunities to meet in person via fitness or hobby-based groups. But 40% of Gen Z in Canada and 32% in the US feel self-conscious making small talk with strangers, and 33% worry about bothering people in public settings. It’s a pattern we first saw in the 2024 Citizen Connections Report: more than half of the 4,000+ people we surveyed globally said they felt less connected than the year before, even as they had access to more ways to connect than ever.

These are all a result of the desire expressed by Gen Z’s embrace of retro tech, collective experiences, shopping malls, and more. They long for the friction erased by smartphones, apps, and life online.

For brands who want to co-author culture and for effective marketing to Gen Z offline, that friction is the opening. 

Reading is a collective experience 

Younger millennials may have started the “analog rebellion,” but Gen Z made it a bonafide movement. News media may report on the embrace of analog tech as a quirk, but our research says otherwise: 60% of Gen Z in the US and 52% in Canada adopted a retro device in the last year. 

Hardware is following demand. Earlier in the year, Noble Mobile partnered with Light Phone on a plan that pays subscribers for staying off their phones, betting that people will pick financial incentive over willpower. At the same time that 25% of Gen Z in the US made the switch to a “dumbphone,” the publishing industry reported an increase in sales in the first half of 2026. Even Wine Enthusiast magazine noticed a trend that more bookstores have added liquor licenses. 

In an effort to connect offline and find new third spaces, Eventbrite reports a 33% increase in book club events in the first half of 2026. Reese Witherspoon’s Hello Sunshine launched a Gen Z-specific offshoot this year, and Audible’s Story House, a free bookless bookstore, saw over 7,000 visitors within a month. We see this as a tactical, mainstream strategy by the first generation raised on algorithms to take back control of their mental health and attention spans.

Malls are back because Gen Z wants somewhere to go

Dozens of movies in the 1980s and 1990s glamourized the excitement of being at the mall for suburban kids across North America. The last 20 years saw a decline in popularity and the proliferation of empty storefronts in malls. But now, younger generations have brought it back. 

According to our research, 1-in-3 Gen Z adults visit a shopping mall weekly with no intention of buying anything. As the media narrative talks about a “retail apocalypse,” brands ahead of the curve are already seeing an opportunity. Kendra Scott’s debut Nashville location features a Hat Customization Atelier and Color Bar. PacSun has switched from closing its store footprint to growing it for the first time in 18 years. SHEIN – an algorithmic digital-first retailer – has invested in physical pop-ups to increase discoverability. 

Gen Z repurposed malls as free, climate-controlled, non-judgmental digital detox spaces. They might not buy big-ticket items, but they report visiting just to walk around (55-60%), meet friends (41-47%), or get a $6 “little treat” (47-52%). As they strive for third spaces, they’ve turned commercial real estate back into a public meeting place.

Introduce the friction of meeting new people

The loneliness epidemic has been cited in the media for the last couple of years. But our latest research shows that nearly 60% of Gen Z feel socially connected. 

Part of the reason is they’ve found new ways to connect offline. Half of Gen Z (52%) use low-tech devices like dumbphones and film cameras. And it isn’t just for aesthetics. Gen Z’s inclination toward an analog rebellion comes from a desire to get out of algorithms and take back control of their mental health and attention spans. 

The most exclusive events in urban centers ban photos or lock up phones altogether. Our research shows that 37% of Gen Z are more likely to attend an event with a phone ban. Yondr, the company behind lockable pouches, has secured more than 20 million phones since 2014, partnering with artists such as Dave Chappelle, Madonna and Bruno Mars. 

In London, The Offline Club runs two-hour phone-free socials several times a month, where guests lock their phones away and spend the evening reading, making things, or talking to strangers, and tickets often sell out days in advance. Most recently, Public School New York hosted a phone-free afterparty during New York Fashion Week, for a night designed for presence and the ultimate experience. 

Run-club sponsorship now sits inside a $97.5 billion global sponsorship market, and the category has stopped being just a running-shoe story. Even brands with nothing to do with fitness have caught on: Netflix built a run-club matchmaking game to promote a recent series, treating the club format itself as marketing infrastructure rather than sponsoring someone else’s.

We take this to mean that young people want to socialize and feel connected, but unscripted casual interactions provoke high anxiety. The explosion of book clubs above and the 78% of Gen Z interested in clubs and other affinity groups bring us to one conclusion: shared activities help break the ice and bring back the welcome friction of participating at a time and place.

Where you fit in

The friction Gen Z is chasing is the invitation for brands. A campaign built for the feed doesn’t land in a room where phones are banned at the door. A discount code doesn’t replace the reason someone shows up every Thursday to run with strangers. Brands need to earn a reason to be in the room with Gen Z. 

It’s not just if your brand shows up in these spaces. It’s whether it knows how to show up, with enough restraint, and not ruin the experience. We’ve been figuring this out through the Citizen GenLens: Gen Z Collective, decoding Gen Z beyond the stereotypes. Get in touch if you want to find your way marketing to Gen Z offline.

Citizen Wins Two Major Honors at the PRNEWS 2026 Platinum Awards

Citizen Relations had a standout evening at the PRNEWS 2026 Platinum Awards this week in New York City, taking home two major accolades. The PRNEWS Platinum Awards celebrate the most innovative, industry-defining public relations campaigns and the trailblazing agencies behind them.

The agency was recognized for its exceptional experiential work, winning Best Pop Up Experience for the Papa Johns ‘Michelin Dining Experience’ campaign. Helping the pizza chain pursue a Michelin Star for its new pan pizza crafted with premium ingredients, the activation was praised for its bold concept and rapid execution, delivering a highly engaging and culturally relevant moment for the brand.

“The success of this campaign shows the power of bold storytelling,” said Erin Georgieff, Managing Partner, US Growth & West Coast Operations. “Taking an idea from pitch to reality in just a matter of weeks, and then earning Best Pop-Up Experience, proves that even on a tight timeline, a great PR campaign stems from great ideas.” 

Citizen Relations was also named to the Agency Elite Top 120 list. This honor places Citizen among an exclusive group of PR and communications agencies that are recognized for setting the pace, driving innovation, and shaping the future of the entire industry.

“Earning a place on the Agency Elite Top 120 shows the relentless drive of our Citizens,” said Laura Bremer, President, U.S. at Citizen Relations. “This recognition goes beyond any single campaign. It signifies that we are consistently operating at the forefront of the industry, challenging conventions, and delivering the highest caliber of work for our partners.”

These latest honors add to an already impressive year for Citizen. In 2026, the agency was recognized at multiple award shows, including 6 wins at The Drum Awards, and 5 wins at ILEA Esprit Awards.

Retail Leaders Beware: How Mallmaxxing and Little Treat Culture Are Redefining Retail

For the past decade, the retail sector operated under a singular directive: optimize for the transaction. 

CMOs and communications leaders spent millions driving immediate foot traffic, scaling performance ad campaigns, and hunting for instant conversions as the threat of e-commerce loomed. Physical stores were measured by one ruthless metric: sales per square foot.

Then came Mallmaxxing and Little Treat Culture.

Our Citizen Intelligence team analyzed results of a human connection study (2,800 adults each across US and Canada), and we realized everyone has been getting the death of physical retail wrong. 

Suburban malls aren’t dying. In fact, Gen Z and Millennials are enthusiastically reclaiming them. The catch? 33% of Canadian Gen Z and 37% of US Gen Z visit a mall or retail space weekly with zero intention of buying anything.

Nearly half (41 to 47%) use retail centers as a convenient meeting spot for friends and family, turning commercial space into a non-commercial living room.

For traditional retail marketers, this presents an existential paradox. How do you market to a generation that fills your physical footprint but refuses to convert at the register?

The Shift: From Point of Sale to Point of Presence

To understand this behavior, communications leaders need to look past traditional retail economic methods and examine modern consumer psychology. 

Younger consumers face severe screen fatigue, and they’re starving for real physical third spaces – a quarter of US Gen Z and nearly 20% of Canadian Gen Z lack a third place. They want places outside of home and work where they can just exist without pressure.

There is no shortage of media headlines highlighting youth isolation, but our data says this is also misguided. Young adults want connection. They’re just dealing with micro-social anxiety, with 1-in-3 worried about bothering people or making awkward small talk.

The mall offers the perfect solution: a climate-controlled, predictable, and unstructured environment for ambient connection. Young adults go to walk around (55 to 60%), people-watch, and absorb crowd energy – gaining a sense of community without the pressure of initiating conversation or navigating awkward interactions.

If your strategy counts non-buyers as wasted impressions, you might be misreading the market. Mallmaxxing proves physical retail’s newest currency isn’t instant conversion. It’s presence, dwell time, and genuine emotional connection.

The Engine: The Psychology of Little Treat Culture

While young consumers put off big-ticket discretionary spending, they aren’t tightening their belts entirely. Instead, they’re guarding their small and mighty indulgences fiercely.

When forced to trim monthly budgets, 41 to 45% of consumers prioritize daily treats like specialty iced lattes, boba, and artisanal pastries, along with dining out (46 to 48%), above physical goods like clothing, electronics, or decor (39 to 40%).

In today’s economy, a $200 jacket feels irresponsible. A $6 specialty drink feels manageable. It delivers instant emotional ROI, a quick dopamine hit, and a brief pause from daily stress.

Here lies the multi-million dollar opportunity for retail brands: little treats build the day-to-day reputation that ultimately drives long-term brand equity.

To capitalize on the convergence of Mallmaxxing and Treat Culture, CMOs and PR Leaders can evolve their experiential and brand strategy in three simple ways.

1. Re-index Store Footprints for Dwelling, Not Just Transacting

If Gen Z uses retail spaces to hang out, give them a reason to hang out inside or near your store. Turn your high density sales spaces into a place worth hanging out – introduce interactive testing stations, conversation-worthy displays and ambient social spaces.

Brands that encourage low-pressure dwelling build organic trust and top-of-mind recall when consumers make a major purchase – which might happen online after seeing products IRL.

2. Front-load the Micro-Indulgence Experience

Consider brand-owned pop-up cafes, strategic partnerships with local specialty beverage brands, or gifting low-friction merchandise. Offer consumers an easy, affordable touchpoint. 

If a consumer leaves your retail location with a $6 branded beverage or snack, they walk away with a positive emotional attachment and a physical billboard in their hand.

3. Reframe PR Narratives Around Community and Well-Being

Consumer PR can’t rely solely on product launches and discount announcements. Media outlets are hungry for stories on how brands are doing something much more interesting – helping to combat digital fatigue and foster real community. 

Find a relevant way to frame your store footprint as a local hub for low-stress human connection, hosting structured gatherings like run clubs, book swaps, or offline social hours.

The Call to Action: Turn Foot Traffic into Brand Loyalty

Make your store something more than a fulfillment centers for physical goods. 

Retailers always face the challenge of turning passive window shoppers into loyal advocates. Embrace mallmaxxing and treat culture to solve this historical challenge – build a long-lasting customer relationship that e-commerce simply can’t touch.

At Citizen, we help global consumer and retail brands decode shifting culture, craft high-impact earned media narratives, and design experiential strategies that convert cultural moments into business growth. If you want to hear more about our ongoing insights and understanding Gen Z, and how to apply them to your business, reach out today.

Citizen Wins 5 Awards at the ILEA Esprit Awards for Global Live Events

Citizens commanded the stage earlier this week at the ILEA Esprit Awards for Global Live Events in Chicago; taking home an impressive haul of five awards across multiple categories. The Esprit Awards recognize the most impactful and innovative live events and experiential marketing campaigns from around the world, and are judged by a panel of industry leaders.

The agency’s standout success of the night was the SickKids 150: #Balloonspotting campaign; taking home three wins for:

  • Best Overall NonProfit/Association Event
  • Best Makes and Impact/Gives Back
  • Best Marketing Campaign

Built to celebrate the hospital’s milestone 150th birthday, the campaign scattered balloon sculptures across 86,500km and launched a giant hot air balloon at the biggest birthday party ever in downtown Toronto.

“To see our events and experiential work recognized on a global stage is an incredibly proud moment for us,” said Kevin Wagman, Managing Director, Experiential at Citizen Relations, and recent winner of the ICON Award at the 2026 Canadian Event Awards. “These wins reflect the incredible dedication and care shown by every member of the Citizen Experiential team. No matter the industry, scale, or audience, we always build meaningful, unforgettable experiences.” 

SickKids was not the only Citizen campaign to shine. The agency also celebrated two major victories for Santa’s Workshop presented by Shoppers Drug Mart, a beautifully crafted and highly engaging consumer holiday activation. The project won:

  • Best Overall Public Event
  • Best Scenic Design, Installation, or Exhibit

“Our holiday work with Shoppers Drug Mart allowed us to design a truly magical, immersive environment for families,” added Wagman. “Both campaigns were highlights for our team to work on.” 

In 2026, the Citizen Experiential team was recognized for their work at the Canadian Event Awards and Drum Awards. These recent accolades highlight Citizen’s continued ability to turn cutting-edge ideas into high-impact events. 

Centering “Corporate Citizenship” in Banking Reputation Management

In an era defined by economic volatility and shifting consumer expectations, financial leaders can no longer treat corporate reputation as a soft public relations metric.
Across North America, reputation is a challenge for the banking industry. While financial institutions are recognized for their products and services, public trust drops sharply when evaluating corporate action, brand promises, and executive leadership.

We surveyed 2,802 Canadian and 2,801 U.S. consumers about their relationship with financial institutions. The results showed us that consumers were concerned with more than just the details of their financial products.

To build long-term trust equity, executive teams need to move beyond functional product marketing and focus on the single strongest driver of consumer trust: corporate citizenship.

The Citizenship Paradox

Consumers consistently state that low fees dictate where they choose to bank.

Our surveys show high-performing products are mandatory to remain competitive, while corporate citizenship is what truly predicts an institution’s overall standing and reputation. In Canada, our survey shows corporate responsibility exerts 46% more impact on overall reputation than products and services, while in the United States, it carries a 17% greater influence.

We found half of North American consumers describe their relationship with their primary bank as a practical or reluctant necessity rather than a trusted partnership. While well-designed mobile apps and loan products may keep accounts open day-to-day, we saw that an institution’s societal behavior and executive accountability dictate whether customers become brand advocates or churn risks during operational friction.

Connecting Purpose to the Customer Experience

Corporate citizenship is too often sequestered in annual ESG reports or ad hoc PR campaigns, disconnected from daily banking interactions. To translate purpose into enterprise value and build trust, financial institutions need to operationalize citizenship directly at consumer touchpoints.

Fairness and transparency of fees represent the single largest performance gap in consumer banking in our research. From our work, we’ve found that when institutions establish plain-language fee transparency frameworks and eliminate predatory penalty fees, they have the opportunity to turn fee structures into proof of ethical behavior.
Second, institutions can embed societal impact into routine financial transactions. Features that allow cardholders to direct micro-contributions from account activity toward local affordable housing, green initiatives, or small business funds turn everyday spending into tangible civic engagement.

Finally, financial wellness must replace transactional utility. Transforming financial institutions and their products from simple balance-checkers into proactive wealth-building partners aligns bank profitability with customer success. When a bank actively protects its customers’ financial health, purpose becomes a daily, lived reality.

Narrative Velocity and Peer Advocacy

Over a quarter of North American consumers we surveyed reported encountering negative news about financial institutions annually resulting in customer defection. Over 70% of consumers who encounter negative news shift their behavior or discontinue product use entirely.

Crucially, corporate communications are among the least trusted sources of information, with only 4% of respondents calling it a trusted source of industry information. Instead, organic word-of-mouth recommendations remain both the most utilized and most trusted channel.

Modern audiences bypass formal brand statements in favor of peer commentary. When an institution consistently delivers on its ethical commitments across every customer touchpoint, word-of-mouth shifts from a churn risk into a self-sustaining driver of customer acquisition.

Banking Reputation Management Requires Leading the Narrative

Bridging the gap between functional execution and institutional trust requires moving from reactive damage control to proactive, PR-led brand strategy.

Navigating reputational volatility requires moving from defensive damage control to proactive brand strategy. Reach out today to learn how our media intelligence engines and intent-tracking capabilities monitor organic customer sentiment across thousands of channels, helping financial leaders identify reputational whitespace and bridge the response gap.

Customer Sentiment Metrics Are Lying to You

For generations, communications leaders have relied on basic metrics to understand public opinion. We counted mentions, tracked share of voice, and sorted comments into positive, neutral, or negative categories.

But today, basic customer sentiment tracking is like checking the weather after the storm has already passed. It’s reactive, superficial, and increasingly dangerous for modern businesses.

As we move through 2026, the speed of information makes tracking obsolete. A brand with high volume and neutral sentiment one day faces a full reputation crisis the next.

This happens because counting mentions only tells us if people are talking. It fails to explain why they are talking, who’s steering the conversation, and how the story is morphing beneath the surface. Crucially, it also completely ignores the silent majority who have stopped talking altogether.

When consumers lose faith in a business, they rarely post negative sentiments about it. They simply walk away in silence. If your tools only monitor active noise, you are entirely blind to this quiet drift of customer defection. To protect your company’s reputation, products, and leaders, we need a new strategy.

This strategy should go beyond sentiment tracking and narrative intelligence to pre-empt customer issues.

A narrative is not just a collection of keywords based on customer feedback. It is an evolving story with a specific path, driven by distinct groups of people. True narrative intelligence tracks the journey of an idea from its origin to its eventual mainstream adoption.

It identifies small, highly motivated communities that create new ideas.

It identifies platforms that speed their spread.

It highlights cultural anxieties that make these ideas resonate.

Consider how modern brand crises unfold

A minor issue in a supply chain or an offhand comment by an executive does not start as a mainstream news story. It begins in niche online forums or localized social groups.

Standard sentiment tools often miss these early signals because the overall volume of mentions is low. By the time volume spikes and triggers an alert, the story is already set. The public has made up its mind. The brand is pushed into a defensive position.

Conversely, the exact same pattern governs the rise of a major market opportunity.

A breakthrough product trend or a new cultural shift starts as a quiet whisper among a small group of passionate advocates in a niche forum. Waiting for standard monitoring tools to flag this behaviour means you only see it after competitors have already capitalized on it.

You’ll be forced to chase a trend that you should have owned.

Owning the Trend

By mapping these cultural currents early, we can understand the trajectory of a story or a market trend before it hits a tipping point.

This is the difference between simply reacting to the market and actively shaping the outcome. It is how we transition from defensive management to proactive narrative leadership. We must stop asking if people are talking and start asking who is driving the story and why it is gaining traction.

Managing reputation in a complex world requires a change in mindset. You can’t protect or drive your business by reacting to the news cycle. You have to anticipate it by understanding the narratives that shape it.

Three Steps to Anticipating Cultural Shifts

If you are concerned that your current monitoring tools are leaving you vulnerable, focus on these immediate priorities.

1. Abandon the volume trap

Stop measuring success by the sheer number of mentions your brand receives. A high volume of shallow engagement is often a distraction from a small but highly influential conversation that is actively shaping public perception and how customers feel.

2. Identify narrative drivers

Look closely at who initiates the conversation and who amplifies it. Understanding the motivations of these key voices allows you to address the root cause of a narrative rather than just treating the symptoms of a public relations issue.

3. Track the velocity of ideas

Monitor how quickly a concept is moving from niche communities to mainstream platforms. By understanding the speed and direction of a story, you can implement pre-cleared communication frameworks before the narrative becomes uncontrollable.

If you’re interested in turning your incisive intelligence into decisive influence, reach out today.

Bridging the Gray Spaces: How Citizen Relations is Rewriting the Agency Blueprint on AI and Innovation

A Q&A with Citizen’s Chief Digital Officer and PRovoke Media Innovator25, Crystalyn Stuart-Loayza, on agency innovation and AI.

Citizen is incredibly proud to celebrate our very own Chief Digital Officer, Crystalyn Stuart-Loayza (CSL), who has been named to PRovoke Media’s prestigious Innovator 25 Americas 2026 list! The annual index recognizes the industry’s most forward-thinking trailblazers; those who are actively challenging conventions, embracing emerging technologies, and driving measurable business impact.

Crystalyn has been innovating in the industry since early on in her career. She’s challenged the norm in a variety of industries and continues to drive transformation in digital marketing today. We sat down with Crystalyn to chat about her philosophy on navigating “gray spaces,” how she is pioneering Citizen’s new responsible AI framework, and why workforce re-imagination is the key to preparing our teams for the future.

On Innovation and Career Evolution

Citizen Relations: From starting out in the ski industry at age 23 to your current role as Chief Digital Officer, how has your definition of innovation evolved?

CSL: I’ve always approached my career as someone focused on the “gray spaces” between disciplines. To me, innovation is not just the continuous pursuit of “looking around the corner” but of mashing things together and creating new possibilities. 

My definition hasn’t  shifted over time so much as it’s evolved with the dynamic technology—which changes every decade—for me it’s always been more about how we work alongside technology. This persistent mindset of adaptability allows us to build an environment that attracts team members who are comfortable with ambiguity and feel permission to explore those uncharted areas and gray spaces bravely.

A Framework for Responsible AI

Citizen Relations: As you drive AI adoption across the Plus Company network, what guardrails must agencies establish to balance rapid technological growth with safety and trust?

CSL: Responsible AI and responsible technology is incumbent upon all of us. It’s always been a critical part of how we embrace and contribute towards the evolution of technology. Responsible AI is a process, not a rigid policy or rules. It requires bringing stakeholders with diverse expertise together in a safe space to solve complex dilemmas.

To support this, we are releasing our first global responsible AI framework. Rather than governing through strict rules, it actively assists employees working alongside AI “toolmates” through four primary pillars:

  • Shifting Human Roles: Defining how roles adapt alongside AI, supported by hands-on upskilling.
  • Responsible Building: Providing frameworks on how to build and implement AI appropriately.
  • Open Disclosure: Encouraging transparency regarding where and how we use AI.
  • Driving Impact Over Hype: Assessing the cost, how it actually helps talent, and its environmental footprint—ensuring we don’t use more energy than needed.

Rethinking Brand Reputation

Citizen Relations: How should brands protect their reputation now that consumers rely so heavily on AI and social discovery?

CSL:  The interesting thing about brand reputation is that you don’t own it—it’s what people perceive of you. The best thing a brand can do is anchor itself in the core needs of its audience and ask: “How can we help?”

By using advanced intelligence to identify connection opportunities, and then leveraging technology to execute solutions at speed and scale, brands can protect, wield, evolve and rebuild their reputation while remaining fresh, relevant and above all, helpful. 

Dismantling Agency Hierarchy: Our “Pod” Structure

Citizen Relations: Citizen has made waves by dismantling traditional agency hierarchy and replacing middle management with implied intelligence and strategy engineers. What drove this pivot and how has it changed the work? 

CSL: Bringing AI toolmates into the workforce is one of the most fundamental shifts in modern history. It necessitates new and emerging skills and change to the team casting and  structure. 

Because we no longer need the exact same legacy skill sets, we have replaced rigid ladders with a flywheel-based model. We organize staff into small, agile, “one pizza pie” teams (pods) with technology at the center.

AI doesn’t replace humans; it transforms jobs. If we aren’t actively helping our talent prepare themselves for that, we will lose control of the technology and fail our precious talent. 

Instead of evaluating promotions on a rigid ladder, we focus on building a “talent spectrum” through individual learning plans. AI empowers this. It allows junior employees to step up into strategic thinking much faster, frees up senior team members to handle tactical work, and lets PR leads make quick, data-driven decisions without needing a constant strategic consult. Crucially, this entire transformation is built on a continuous feedback loop with our teams and our clients.

Conversational Intelligence and Commercial Outcomes

Citizen Relations: How are tools like conversational intelligence and a “whole search” approach helping prove that PR is a measurable driver of hard business outcomes?

CSL: The industry narrative shifts when you can directly connect a PR investment to hard, commercial results.

By investing in conversational intelligence and a “whole search” approach, we feed our teams with unparalleled insights into culture, competitor landscapes, and consumer behavior. This lets us design highly targeted campaigns and build out the entire customer funnel—measuring the experience from initial awareness all the way down to brand loyalty, ultimately showing clearer and more fulsome impact.

Advice for the Next Generation of Innovators

Citizen Relations: What advice would you give to other leaders facing internal resistance to change?

CSL: First, use data to neutralize fear. By anchoring your discussions in education, data, and concrete insights, you ground the conversation in something safe and comfortable.

Second, build “brave spaces”. Successful change management requires creating environments where people feel safe to try, fail, and learn without the pressure of needing to get everything perfect on the first attempt.

Finally, take the pressure off yourself. It is an anxious, high-pressure time to be an innovator. There is no single “right” answer. We simply need to collaborate, listen to each other, and make our absolute best collective effort.

From Signal to Strategy: Where Gut Meets Data

In a world where narratives can move from a whisper to a headline in hours, managing a brand’s reputation on gut instinct alone is a liability. When crises take shape in real time, reacting after the fact is simply too late.

To stay ahead, modern reputation management demands a new playbook: blending old-school intuition with new-school data intelligence. Reading the room isn’t enough anymore. We have to catch the quiet signals before they get loud, and use actual data to make the call.

Two Citizen leaders, Suran Ravi, SVP Applied Intelligence & Studio, and Aly Sturm, SVP and Reputation+ lead, discuss how Citizen and clients are navigating this shift.

How are you seeing clients leverage (or not leverage) proactive reputation management right now?

SURAN: Too often, clients wait until an issue becomes a full-blown crisis before investing in their communications strategy. It’s the equivalent of buying rain boots only after the storm hits. As an industry, we need to do a better job demonstrating that proactive reputation management is actually a form of risk mitigation. By quantifying how early preparation protects enterprise value and prevents revenue degradation, we can shift the conversation from communications being a reactive expense to a critical, proactive investment.

ALY: Clients increasingly realize the next crisis is a matter of when, not if. Yet, many still lack formal rapid-response frameworks and would be forced to scramble in real time. The most resilient companies take a proactive approach, combining stakeholder input with data-driven risk assessments. Often, what internal teams perceive as the biggest threat differs completely from what the data reveals. The strongest programs bridge this gap by pairing signals with strategy – using data to identify actual vulnerabilities, and governance to manage them before they escalate.

In your experience working with leaders client side, what have you found has kept them from addressing intelligence gaps or investing in gathering the right signals to bolster their strategies?

SURAN: Almost every comms team today is sitting on a wealth of data. The challenge isn’t getting the data – it’s unlocking its value. Too often, teams miss out on opportunities simply because the organization’s Data & Analytics talent is siloed in other departments. True intelligence requires outfitting comms teams with embedded analytical talent who actually understand the nuances of our industry. When you put them in the mix rather than parking them elsewhere, everything changes. That’s exactly how we operate at Citizen; our pod structure allows our strategists and comms consultants to work side-by-side with our applied intelligence team in a flywheel motion where the work and counsel is constantly being shaped by relevant strategic insights that can only be unlocked through this level of thoughtful integration.

Are we optimizing for control when we should be optimizing for response?

ALY: Absolutely. In our industry, we often confuse collecting data with having control. We build dashboards and assume that seeing the landscape means we are ready for a crisis. But data only gives you the proof – it tells you what is happening. Without the process – the governance, the clear escalation paths, and the rapid-response frameworks – you aren’t actually prepared to do anything about it. You can have perfect visibility into what the market is doing, but if you don’t have the internal process to act on it, you’re just watching it happen. Optimizing for response means pairing your intelligence with a system that can actually turn insights into immediate action.

Are we relying too heavily on dashboards and missing what actually matters? Have we confused monitoring with actual strategy?

SURAN: I am not sure how this came about but comms teams love nothing more than having a dashboard that was built for them. How important is it to have one? Very. What value does it provide? Marginal. Seeing what’s happening seems to be a prerequisite for “being prepared” which I understand to a degree – but comms dashboards are optimized for the wrong signals. If you can’t look at a dashboard and make a decision in a few minutes, it’s not serving its purpose. Having the KPIs or building the right ones to make decisions is valuable, but that’s not about a dashboard. You do that work outside of the dashboard, and should you need that KPI accessible on-demand you can embed it into your dashboard with the appropriate data freshness set to ensure the KPI is relevant when you need to make decisions using it.

How do you use specific data points to convince leadership that “doing nothing” is actually the right move sometimes?

ALY: To convince leadership that strategic silence is the right move, you have to prove that reacting will actually create the crisis they are trying to avoid. Executives naturally have a bias for action, but when you use data to prove an issue is isolated to a vocal minority or a closed echo chamber, you reframe ‘doing nothing’ as ‘refusing to give the issue oxygen.’ You show them that an official corporate response won’t kill the story – it will only legitimize the criticism and introduce the threat to a broader audience that otherwise never would have seen it.

The Future of Branded Content Might Not Be Content At All

We are officially in the post social media era. What was once a set of channels connecting you with your friends has been fully replaced by a world of strangers and AI slop. And you don’t need a crystal ball to see how the internet itself will soon be nearly all machine-made content. Meanwhile, brands are still out here playing the same game where content is king. 

It’s not hard to see why this is not a winning formula anymore. We’ve gone from connection to consumption. What was once about keeping people engaged and connected has turned into something even simpler… keep people scrolling. 

For the platforms the benefit of your time online is the creation of endless data points, with every view, swipe, or tap being sold to the highest bidder. 

But for brands? What’s the value in the endless content we make?

A quick observation: A completed 15-second view of your video equates to an average of 0.08% of a person’s daily phone time.

While the practice of advertising through reach and frequency, engineering breakthrough creative, and relevant messaging against owned audiences is still an incredible value, many brands lack the platform to maximize the value of the creative firehose they’ve built. Afterall, this is a trillion dollar war we’re in for a fraction of a percent of a person’s attention.

So, how do brands actually win?

We must move beyond content for content sake. I believe brands that shift from Content as King, to The Utility King are the ones that will endure in this next era of marketing. Brands that stop making things to watch and start building things to use will win the time and valuable attention from their audiences. The shift to make is to move from someone giving your brand 0.05% of their daily phone time, to instead giving people a reason to keep coming back to you. By taking time to solve a nuanced, annoying little problem at no added cost, the brand can forge new relationships and show up for consumers in more impactful ways. 

Three ways to start doing this today:

  1. Give the people what they’re searching for: By tapping into user-intent research, brands can categorize and prioritize critical areas of consumer needs in their category, or within the product lifecycle. Pin-pointing these needs unlocks opportunities for the brand to be of service to their customers by helping them overcome their biggest challenges and questions. Content creation can be meaningful, by feeding a channel like YouTube, a massively underused option where long-term utility content has durability to continue to show up years after publishing (unlike the daily churn for attention in feeds). 
  2. Go beyond content: By making a simple solution that answers specific consumer needs, at no added costs, brands can infuse themselves in new ways to a consumer’s daily routine. For example, the other day I noticed that the Golf Now app didn’t have the courses closest to my house (there were about nine of them just missing). So in 30 minutes (and with zero coding skill) I built a functioning app to serve up those tee times. Brands that are able to prototyping a consumer-ready solution will yield more than just watch-time, it will put your brand into their daily habits.
  3. If you must do content, coordinate it: We call this flooding-the-zone. Your PR team chasing Gen-Z, while your social team partners with mom-fluencers, and your DR campaigns segmenting your audiences based on behaviors alone will leave your brand fragmented in the market-place. By atomizing consistent content themes across all those channels will deliver outsized impact from brand consistency (and positively impact your brand’s discoverability with the LLMs)

When the internet is 99% AI slop, the only way to survive is to be the 1% that actually works. If I’m working brand side, I’m on a mission to stop trying to win the Attention War and start winning the Reliability War. “How does this help the customer?” is my guiding question going forward. Because building trust through value is a much better look than begging for 0.05% of scroll time. 

What do you think will be mission critical for branded content in the future?

If you enjoyed this and want to chat more sometime, I’d love to hear from you.